7 Wedding Favor Mistakes to Avoid

True or false: the best wedding favors are those that are planned in advance. True! Favors have become customary to give at weddings for good reason: guests celebrate + support you on the biggest day of your life. So, it’s only appropriate to give a token of your appreciation on the day of your wedding. But did you know that some couples make simple favor mistakes that can cause these charming gifts to be missed or left at tables altogether? Today, we’re sharing a few wedding favor mistakes to avoid to ensure your favors rock your wedding. Read on to find out what we’ve uncovered…

wedding favor mistakes

by the mason bar company

Wedding Favor Mistakes

Avoid these common wedding favor mistakes:

Wedding Favor Mistakes #1: The Throwaway Favor

Favors can be pricey, particularly when you have a large guest list. However, don’t fall victim of buying a cheap favor for the sake of having something. A cheap favor that guests will never use, keep, or remember isn’t worth a penny. Instead, make something at home that’s inexpensive – yet heartfelt – like a batch of sugar cookies. Or ANY of these amazing edible favor ideas. Place one treat in a brown paper bag and a decorative stamp. Easy? Yes. Better and cheaper than store-bought? You bet.

Wedding Favor Mistakes #2: Lack of Meaning

Even the simplest favor can mean something. Use your wedding favor to tell guests something about your unique story. For instance, say you met at a coffee shop in college and bonded over your favorite mocha blend. A wedding favor you may wish to give would be a small favor bag filled with whole coffee beans. This favor is not simply a bag of coffee: it’s a sweet sentiment and ode to your story.

wedding coffee favors

by apropos roasters

Wedding Favor Mistakes #3: Poorly Packaged

The simplest favor can be wedding-ready in no time with proper packaging. Similarly, a more elaborate favor can lose its luster with poor wrapping or none altogether. If you’re giving a favor that’s store-bought, put your own personalized spin on it by adding a little handmade charm. Rip off that individual plastic wrapping, tear away the generic ‘thank you’ tag, and add your own ribbon, wedding tag, or label to make it your own. As an example, consider a handmade tag like these by Dondalee’s which can include a fun stamp that ties into your decor…

wedding favor tags

wedding favor tags

… or add a cute chalkboard label by Design Circus

wedding chalkboard labels

by design circus

… or even a personalized stamp, like this one by Paper Sushi…”

personalized wedding stamp

by paper sushi

Wedding Favor Mistakes #4: The Complicated DIY Favor

Okay, Pinterest addicts: you, like me, ooh and aah over the clever DIY ideas and trendy gifts you’re determined to make as wedding favors, right? But, there truth is that unless one has a DIY-driven team of dedicated ribbon-tiers, pie-bakers, or blue mason jar acquirers crafting 100+ favors around the clock, you may want to keep the favor DIY to a minimum. Find one that is easy-to-complete well ahead of time, is affordable, the supplies are easy to acquire, and the project won’t drive you batty before the big day. Stress = no fun for anyone, especially the bride. I’ve heard horror stories of brides losing steam before the big day and stayed up tying bows or baking pies in jars right before the wedding because it sounded like a good idea at the time. Keep your sanity and select your DIY wisely./p>

Wedding Favor Mistakes #5: The Confusing Favor

This is one of my favorites because it can happen easily without you even realizing it… don’t make guests guess what the favor is. For instance, if giving a jar filled with cookie mix as a favor, include a label with the ingredients (particularly for allergies) along with the directions on how to make the cookies. Make sure the jar is well sealed and preserved and store in a cool, dry place until the wedding day. Similarly, if you’re giving a gift that’s edible, include a label and a utensil. You’d be surprised how many guests look at tiny treats with a puzzled look because they’re not sure what’s in it, they aren’t sure when to eat it (before? after? take to-go?), and they have no utensils to use. Make it simple for guests and spell it out.

wedding favor bag

by clementine weddings

Wedding Favor Mistakes #6: The Limited Supply Favor

Sometimes, a guest may show up unexpectedly, when he or she never sent in an RSVP. Or, Great Aunt Martha wants to take home an extra favor to show to her friends at Bingo. With your favors being pre-planned and totally kick-you-know-what, expect that a few guests may want to take a few extras just in case. So, have a few added into the rotation (and don’t forget about one for you and your groom – you’d be surprised how many couples skip themselves or forget to grab one as a keepsake). One of the most popular favors? Jam favors like these!

wedding favor jam

similar jars by southern jams and jelly

Wedding Favor Mistakes #7: The Forgotten Favor

One awesome idea is to give away favors that can be used during your wedding by guests and them taken come and re-used. One example is a mason jar drinking glass, which the guest can write his or her name on (with a simple tag + marker or chalkboard paint + chalk, pre-made) and use to fill up with drinks throughout the night. The caveat: make sure guests know to take them home as favors. Otherwise, you’ll have 100+ mason jars left over after the party to pack up and find a place to store AND guests will totally miss that you even offered a favor. One way to combat this is with a sign placed clearly at the drink table with instructions for guests.

* * *

Join the discussion:

Fill in the blank: “I’m giving away ___________ as my wedding favor!” (Share below)


Like it? Share it ↓
P.S. Subscribe NOW - it's free and you'll get updates to your inbox! Click here!

This post may contain affiliate links. See disclosure for details.

Don't miss these ↓

groomsmen gift ideas  bridesmaid gift ideas

Leave a Comment

109 Comments on "7 Wedding Favor Mistakes to Avoid"

Notify of
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Sharon Smalley

For my daughters wedding we put together an antique key shaped bottle opener hung around an 8 oz bottle of Martinellis Sparkling Cider with a small tulle bow.


I’m giving each guest a half dozen , homemade salted caramels- wrapped in stripped and floral wax wrappers then into a small bag w/personalized sticker. I make them every holiday and have people constantly requesting them . It just feels like the right, personal touch and I’ll enjoy making them :)
– wedding less than a year away, 150 attending

Tosha Patchin

I made diy magnets with 2inch flat glass gems with a photo of my fiance and I and our wedding date. Made simply with mod podge, a printer to print out mini photos, and a 1 inch round magnet. I packaged each into a small gift bag and ribbon in our wedding colors.


I’d leave this one behind on the table, no offense.


I\’m using hand made soap favors for my wedding. Reliable, can order in advance, easy to package. I had a custom bulk order off of etsy. I really wanted to treat my quests because many are traveling, and I wanted something I knew they would use.

I ordered 5 loaves of Goatsmilk Bentonite Clay Soap scented with Oatmeal and Honey.

5 loaves = 55 full 3inch bars, cost me $108, shipping included. Less than 2 dollars a favor for soaps that usually cost $5 a piece.


My wedding is in about a year and a half, and I’m starting my planning early! I have the idea of a fairy tale wedding, with a hint of Beauty and the Beast (but without being overpowering-ly Disney.) I’m looking for subtle and classy, I’m hoping to just have tea coffee and appetizers/tea cakes at my reception and I figured a cute favor, but heart-felt would be small jars of local honey. The problem I’m running into is what size jar is appropriate? I feel like 1oz jars would be good (and cheaper), but I’m really not sure. any ideas?


Correction….$6.92 a case. The other price was an oval hex. Even better.


We’re using 1.5 oz jars. Lone Star Candle Supply has 1.5 oz hex jars for $8.44 a case (24). Lids are a bag of 144 for $14.99 and bags of 12 for $1.49. So far that’s one of the best deals I’ve found. I got 2 1/2 gallons of local honey for $120. I’m looking at roughly $250 for @ 210 jars after printing labels and tying with ribbon or such.


What about making a fruit butter, yummy jam, or small mason jar pie? These have been my favorite favors, and you can really personalize them with a cute string and “thank you” label

Lisa Carlsen

I’m planning on doing the local honey also and I think I’m going with a 4oz jar.


You can buy a bulk supply of raw honey on amazon for cheap, search bulk raw honey. The best deal I saw was larger order 12 lbs for $68 – not sure how many guests youre expecting but even if you did decide on a larger size jar, that is still a significant deal to spend per person.