Are you looking for the best personalized baby gifts Etsy has to offer right now? We browsed high and low to bring you the trends gifts for new moms and babies that are absolutely adorable. Read on + subscribe to our newsletter for the latest baby finds to your inbox!

Do you know a new mom or mama to be? Want to surprise her with a few baby gifts she can get personalized for her little one?

Or maybe you’re expecting a baby soon and you want to buy a few personalized baby gifts yourself! I understand. :) Being verrrrry pregnant at the moment, add to cart is my middle name when it comes to baby gifts. Has a nice ring to it, no? :) Especially when it comes to personalized baby gifts Etsy has to offer right now. There are so many adorable, want-it-need-it baby gift ideas right now and it was actually tough to condense this list into a top ten, tbh.

From personalized baby gifts like rattles or paci clips to luxuriously soft minky blankets, we have the best personalized baby gifts Etsy offers right now. These trendy new mom gifts (or moms who have little ones, but are expecting a new addition to her crew!) are great ideas for now through the spring and summer months.

And best of all, these baby gift ideas are all handmade!

Yup, that’s right: each baby gift is personalized just for you, and also made by a small business so you’re shopping small for your little one. Win-win!

And while these are personalized baby gifts, you’ll find many of them are also really personalized gifts for new mom to enjoy. After all, who doesn’t love a sweet, custom gift for their little babe? These make great heirlooms!

P.S. Not sure? Send one of these instead!

Let’s get started!

1. Personalized Baby Blanket with Name

We’re starting the list with one of the most classic, yet currently trendy new mom gifts Etsy has to offer: baby blankets with his or her name personalized on them.

Baby blankets are a unique gift that moms are buying for their little ones, husbands are buying to surprise wives ahead of baby’s arrival, and grandparents are buying up like hotcakes (especially when they know the name of the baby ahead of time).

We keep baby names totally close-to-the-vest before they arrive. What do you do? Even if you aren’t telling anyone the name yet, personalized baby blankets with name OR without make great gifts. The baby blanket can still be personalized by selecting a theme that matches the nursery, or colors and styles of the season of his or her birth.

The personalized baby blankets at Emmiebel Studio are unlike any we’ve seen before. They’re luxuriously soft; unlike most blankets you’ll find elsewhere, THESE are double-sided blankets with a sweet, curated design on the front and plush minky on the back.

You can choose from many different designs to coordinate with your nursery, favorite colors, etc. And add embroidery if you’d like to make your baby blanket personalized with your little one’s name on it.

These are just a few of the popular styles of blankets in the Emmiebel Studio. See the full collection here.

This is undoubtedly the best personalized baby gift for a boy or a girl. Everyone can use a blanket and it’s extremely versatile: take it with you, snuggle on the couch, etc. I love this as a gift!

2. Baby Name Rattle

These handmade silicone baby name rattles make a sweet personalized gift for him or her. Choose the name, the color combination, and the style. These are FDA-approved 100% food-grade silicone; not to be used as a bracelet, but as a grasping toy or rattle. No BPA! Handmade by MintedAve. Cute!

3. Personalized Animal Lovey Toy

Yeah, this is pretty adorable if you ask me! This animal lovey makes one of the best personalized baby gifts Etsy has to offer from maker BurtonBabyDesign. It can be embroidered with baby’s name, or if you’re not sure of the name yet, just skip it and just get the lovely itself. Seriously, it’s cute with or without the name on it!

4. Slouchy Baby Hats for Boys

This is probably the trendiest personalized baby gifts Etsy has for baby boys, honestly! It’s slouchy, has that fun modern vibe, and will look great and grow with him. It features a nice large leather personalized tag on the front with his name in a cool script. By TinAndSteele. You HAVE TO see these with photos of real babes wearin’ them — too cute! — in the shop here.

5. Baby Girl Bows

And for the baby girls, a box of bows! These can be personalized if you’d like! You can also make a box of baby bows and include some rattles, which are also super-cute. The colors of these are adorable! By MamaBearAndCubsShop.

6. Personalized Nursery Name Night Light

People are going crazy over this nursery name night light and it’s for good reason: it’s adorable to see your baby’s name all lit up AND it makes the perfect amount of light in the nursery for those late-night changes. There’s never enough light in the nursery, yet you need a little glow to see what you’re doing without waking up the baby! This is the solution — and it makes one of the best personalized baby gifts Etsy has to offer right now. By LoveLottieXOXO.

7. Personalized Baby Bibs

A little dribble, no problem! These sweet bandana-style bibs are personalized with his or her name (and middle, if you’d like!) and aren’t just cute, they’re totally functional, too. People are raving about the quality of these! By MyLittleSquash. Pair it with the adorable baby rattle for sweet and trendy gifts for new moms.

8. Knotted Baby Gown Personalized

Someone asked me recently what my favorite new baby gift was, or what is “trending” at the moment. The answer: knotted baby gowns! And if the knotted baby gown is personalized, it’s even better; add a knotted baby hat and, get out! That’s adorable! :) There’s something about the super-soft organic cotton, the colors, the knot at the bottom, and the knotted hat that makes this one of the best personalized baby gifts Etsy has to offer from many sellers, all in their own niche. These make AWESOME first baby photo accessories and are wonderful for changing baby in the middle of the night. No snaps or buttons here to drive you crazy in the middle of the night when you’re already sleep-deprived. Knots are so much easier! By SongbirdCelebrations.

9. Baby Crib Shoes

Okay, these aren’t necessarily personalized baby gifts, but they are adorable so whatever, I’m putting them here. :) I say they can be personalized based on the theme or colors you pick, whichever you think the baby’s parents would like. I mean, when is the last time you saw AVOCADO crib shoes and a pair that looked this adorable?! By DesertGreenHC.

Baby crib shoes make one of the best baby gifts Etsy has for new moms because most won’t splurge on baby crib shoes, since they’re quickly too small, but they sure are fun to have when they are wearing ’em!

10. Personalized Owl Baby Toy

This owl is the cutest thing. It is personalized on the front and there’s just something about the face: it’s so kind and gentle and would be such a sweet welcome home baby gift for your little one. By AmyLucyDesigns.

And there you have it: the 10 best personalized baby gifts Etsy has to browse, shop, and enjoy! These make terrific non-registry baby gifts for new moms. They’re also supporting local or handmade artists, so you’re shopping small when you purchase.

We kept this to a top ten list, but you may also like these finds:

– these baby name puzzles are pretty awesome

– this inkless handprint / footprint kit is a great gift

– these closet dividers come in handy

– a simple and sweet frame like this is a great first-photo gift for new moms

and

– this complete baby gift set is terrific for sending to new moms via mail

We hope you enjoyed this gift guide! Which baby gift= is your favorite?

Happy Mama-ing!

xo
Emma