Hoping to find heart shaped jewelry that aren’t cringe worthy? You’re in the right place! We found jewelry you’ll love to wear from heart-shaped necklaces to earrings, rings, and bracelets! Get inspired below and subscribe for the latest to your inbox.

While it’s a classic choice, is it possible to find heart shaped jewelry that isn’t cringe?

This is the question I asked myself when I saw yet another commercial for Valentine’s Day that highlighted the same tacky baubles and diamond-filled heart jewelry we’re so over seeing these days. I knew there had to be something better out there: you know, heart shaped jewelry that isn’t tacky. Or cheesy. Or cringe worthy. :)

If you’re on the hunt for a beautiful heart-shaped necklace, bracelet, or ring that looks lovely and doesn’t feel like a cheap bauble just for Valentine’s Day, look no further. I’m rounding up the best handmade (yay, shop small!) jewelry gifts in heart shapes with plenty of modern pieces that won’t break the bank — or look cheesy. :)

► Maybe you’ll treat yourself.

► Perhaps you’ll surprise your fave Galentine.

► Or you’ll buy it for someone special in your life.

Either way, I promise these heart necklaces, earrings, and bracelets won’t make you cringe and are certainly not tacky. Let’s get started!

Before we get to the list, let’s talk about what gives modern heart shaped jewelry a more updated look.

Modern Heart Shaped Jewelry with an Uplifted Look

When shopping for a heart-shaped necklace or bracelet, be on the look out for minimalist style. Minimalist jewelry is very popular right now and is suitable for everyday wear. Since most people aren’t going to ballrooms and elegant parties every weekend, wearing a simple piece of personalized jewelry makes more sense.

Can you wear it all the time? Yes? Then it makes a perfect gift!

What Makes a Quality Heart-Shaped Jewelry Piece?

Don’t look to the price when it comes to quality, as sometimes you’ll pay more for a piece of jewelry you can get done elsewhere from a smaller business. Large jewelry corporations charge more because, well, they can! I love to shop handmade whenever possible because you’ll find quality pieces at a fraction of the cost and the money goes directly to a small business owner who does a happy dance when you order. :)

A nice gift + good quality + supporting small business? That’s a win-win-win.

Now that you know what to search and where to find it, here are the best places for heart shaped jewelry that won’t make you cringe.

1. Dainty Heart Necklace, $29

I’m loving the sweet simplicity of this heart-shaped necklace by Rustic Gem Jewelry. Get it here.

2. Tiny Heart Necklace, $21.25

This necklace is popular now and is on sale! Known for its tiny, minimalist style, this heart-shaped necklace isn’t cheesy at all. It’s perfect for wearing solo or layered with other necklaces. By MinthologieStudio. Get it here while the sale lasts.

3. Heart Locket, $29.40

Get this heart-shaped locket necklace while it lasts at this price because it’s 30% off for a limited time. By Caitlyn Minimalist, this is one of my favorite heart-shaped jewelry pieces that aren’t at all tacky or cheesy. It’s a locket, which makes it even more meaningful; put your favorite photo inside to keep close to your heart. Get it here.

4. Double-Heart Necklace in Sterling Silver, $27.20

Currently on sale, this double-heart necklace is two hearts in one for a unique style you’ll love to wear. By Rustic Gem Jewelry. See it here.

5. Love Knot Ring, $20.30

This is one of my favorite jewelry pieces with a heart at the forefront, without being tacky. It’s a love knot ring, perfect for you, your special someone, or as a sweet bridesmaid gift idea. Get it here. By CaitlynMinimalist.

6. Dainty Sparkly Heart Necklace, $17.12+

Normally priced around $40+, this necklace is on sale. It has a small heart but will make a big impression on someone special in your life! By HandmadeDaintyUS. See it here.

7. Heart Shaped Hoop Earrings, $23.10

Wow! Be right back as I add these to cart. ;) What a pretty pair of earrings! I love this hoop/huggie style and the heart adds a whole shape to it. Get these earrings here. By CaitlynMinimalist.

8. Elongated Heart Necklace in Gold, $23

These heart necklaces are wildly popular among reviewers and a staple on Etsy for years! Get yours at Gigglosophy. Shop here.

9. Heart Pearl Earrings, $16.45

Simple stud earrings but with a pearl finish and a sweet heart-shape! By CaitlynMinimalist. Shop here.

10. Lariat Necklace with Heart and Gemstone, $24

A pretty necklace for the person who loves a little heart shape with a powerful pop of color. By Rustic Gem Jewelry. See it here.

11. Heart Fingerprint Ring, $22.05

You send a picture of the actual fingerprint(s) and it’s engraved on this ring! What an incredible idea. By CaitlynMinimalist. Buy here.

12. + 13. + 14. Dainty See-Through Choker Necklace, $20.95+

This lovely necklace is dainty and perfect for layering or wearing as-is. By EastonLaneJewelry. I love all three styles of heart necklaces from this shop, so I’m sharing all three below. See them here.

15. Large Open Heart Necklace, $39.28

Gosh, I love this piece! It’s so simple yet so sweet. Get it at JadedSB. Shop here.

16. Heart-Shaped Bracelet with Actual Handwriting, $32.55+

Upload a note or signature and have it engraved on the charm in the actual handwriting. This is such a sweet and sentimental gift! By CaitlynMinimalist. Buy here.

17. Personalized Heart Bracelet, $33.60

This heart-shaped bracelet is one of my favorites of this list. It’s so minimalist and perfect for daily wear. By FeminaHandmade. Shop here.

/a>

18. Tiny Heart Ring, $20.30

This incredibly dainty ring makes the perfect modern heart-shaped jewelry that isn’t tacky in the least. Wear it solo or layer it with your other stacking rings. By CaitlynMinimalist. Buy here.

Jewelry with a heart shape isn’t necessarily tacky. If you pick a style that is more minimalist and suited to the individual, you’ll find out that heart shaped jewelry that won’t make you cringe and we can definitely appreciate that. :)

SHOP NOW: If you’re looking for heart shaped jewelry that won’t make you cringe, start shopping today! Click on a photo or link above to see more details. Or click the social media buttons below to share this post with your family and friends who may need to find the perfect piece of heart-shaped jewelry.