Looking for the most unique Valentines Day gifts 2023 has to offer on Etsy? We’ve found ’em! All sixty-four of them, to be exact! But first, join our newsletter for free!

Do you need the best Valentine’s Day gift to win the exchange this year? :) Do you want something they don’t already have… you know, something unique? You’ve come to the right place!

It may be a little early, but picking out the perfect gift for your Valentine takes thoughtful consideration.

And if you’re shopping online, you’ll also want to add in some shipping time, as well. To help you find the perfect present, we’re rounding up the best Valentines gifts Etsy has to offer for 2023 including ALL handmade gift ideas for him or her.

With over sixty hand-picked finds, you’re sure to find something for someone special.

P.S. Save this list: it might come in handy for birthdays, wedding gifts, bridesmaid gifts, and groomsmen gifts. Enjoy!

Best Valentines Day Gifts Etsy: 2023

1. This what I love about you book

What a great idea! By RusticoUSA.

2. These XO stacking rings

Want, need! These are one of the best valentine’s day gifts for her. Get them at NOLIAjewelry.

3. This leather wallet

By Holtz Leather.

4. These heart dangle earrings

Ahh, these are fun. By IndigoClayJewelry.

5. This vintage folding heart locket necklace

By Silk Purse Sows Ear.

6. This watch box

Display his favorite watches in this cool, modern watch display box. By MijMojDesign.

7. This “you sir are exceptionally handsome” toiletry bag

By Alphabet Bags.

8. These gold bead bracelets for her

By Ava Hope Designs.

9. This hidden message inside bracelet for him

By PorterandHazel.

10. This ticket stub shadow box

Save those stubs! By Torched Products.

11. This box of reasons why you love him/her

Write one down for every week of the year, i.e. “your smile”, “our Netflix and chill nights”, “your ability to make me laugh”, etc. By 52 Reasons Why.

12. This beautiful red garnet bracelet for her

By Laura Stark Jewelry Studio.

And this gorgeous heart necklace (also by Laura Stark Jewelry Studio):

13. This “wheelie like you” keychain

For your biker bf/hubby/gf/wife. By C and T Custom Lures.

14. This heart bracelet in gold

By Tales in Gold

15. Tiny leather key holder

One of the best minimalist and unique Valentine’s Day gifts for her or him in 2023! By zeynNY.

16. Glass blown mini vases

Handmade and absolutely beautiful. By MariaidaDesigns.

17. A hilarious Valentines Day card for him or her

I love ALL OF THESE by HellaFreshDesigns. These are hilarious!

18. This gold ring dish

I adore this one! For holding jewelry or keys. By ThePaintedPress.

19. This pair of knitted heart mittens

So cozy + cute! By TangledKnotco.

20. This heart and arrow barrette

By Kapelika.

21. These wooden heart spoons

By ModParty.

22. This “I reel-y like you” lure

So cute! By C and T Custom Lures.

23. This heart coffee spoon/scoop

For the coffee lover in your life. By BeehiveHandmadeLLC.

24. Taco night seasoning set

Mix up your taco night with this savory seasoning set. By CalicuttsSpiceCo.

25. This beard oil and conditioning set

By WildRoseHerbs.

26. A cute plant pick

By HereafterLA.

27. This custom fishing lure

By C and T Custom Lures.

28. These heart stud earrings

By Ravit Schwartz.

29. These paper roses that last forever

These flowers never wilt. By VEN Decor.

30. These gemstone stud earrings

By Tom Design Shop.

31. This engraved wood watch for him

By Wild Watches.

32. This DIY crossbow kit for him

By Decoloris Shop.

33. This mini photo album keychain

By UniqueGiftLove.

34. These cozy Valentine’s socks for her

So chic! By PARKERmadeShop.

35. These matching initial rings

It forms your initials when placed together. Love this! By CADI Jewelry.

36. This personalized cap catcher

By Cap Catchers.

37. This personalized vinyl record display

This makes a truly unique Valentine’s day gift for him or her. By MiniDecorShop.

38. This heart keychain set

Twinning! By HeartsForFriendship.

39. This toiletry case with monogram

By MirageLeather.

40. This fun drink infusion kit

You can DIY together! By DoYourGin.

41. This electronics docking station

By FortisFinds.

42. These tasty bbq rubs

For the griller in your life. By GustoSpice.

43. This pair of heart-shaped wood cufflinks

These are one of the best Valentines Day gifts 2023 has to offer! By One Happy Leaf.

44. This engraved picture wallet insert

Love this idea. It’s so simple, yet perfect. Get it VintageBrandingCo.

45. This name necklace

She’ll love it. Get it at Caitlyn Minimalist.

46. This personalized name ring for her

By Abhika Jewels.

47. These scratch off love coupons

Write your own messages! By Inklings Paperie.

48. One of these “blessing band” bracelets

Include a message you know she’ll love. By Amy Waltz.

49. This guitar pick

By C and T Custom Lures.

50. This initial necklace for him

Very stylish. By SHOPEVREN.

51. This giant chunky knit blanket

Many colors and sizes available! By ChunkyWoolStudio.

52. And these with initials

Also obsessing over these, by Talkin Gloves:

53. This photo keychain

By Memorable Keeps.

54. These solid gold heart earrings

By everlijewelry.

55. This personalized underwear for him

By 78MagnoliaLane.

56. This X O earring set

By Lex Luxe.

56. This heart and arrow pint glass

Personalized! Get it Vital.

57. These heart fingerless gloves

Comfy! By Ornute.

58. These yours and mine coasters

By Clouds and Currents.

59. These cute huggy candles

Definitely one of the most unique Valentine’s day gifts for him or her. By CaiCaiHandmade.

60. This duffle bag for him

By JoyfulTidingsBridal.

61. This handmade heart pillow

By HelloHappyHandmade.

62. This “I cerealsy love you” cereal spoon

Cute! By CustomSpoonGuy.

63. These cheesy + fun face socks

By FabSwag.

64. This custom portrait

Display it at home! So cute. By NibiruDesign.

So, tell me: what’s your favorite from this list?

Happy Planning (+ Valentine’s Day gift exchanging!)

xo
Emma

P.S. Popping the question this Valentine’s Day? Read: 100 Best Non-Traditonal Engagement Rings and 40 Most Beautiful Engagement Rings on Etsy.