Home | 7 Tips for Picking an Engagement Ring

7 Tips for Picking an Engagement Ring

by Emma Arendoski

Are you (or someone you know) popping the question soon and shopping for an engagement ring? Understandably, it may seem a bit overwhelming at first. After all, there’s so much time, energy, money, and thought that goes into picking the perfect engagement ring. What style does she like? How much should I spend? Where do I start looking? Should I look for custom handmade rings or buy from a large chain? Does she want a diamond or an alternative engagement ring? Today we’re sharing seven tips for picking an engagement ring to help you shop. Read on to find out more…

7 Tips for Picking an Engagement Ring

barbara michelle jacobs

7 Tips for Picking an Engagement Ring

1. Pay attention to the style and shape she likes best.

Besides knowing about the 4 C’s (cut, color, clarity, and carat), it is essential to know what shape stone she likes best. Some examples are pear, marquise, princess, emerald and round, just to name a few.

Beau-coup Wedding Favors

round engagement ring solitaire via 7 Tips for Picking an Engagement Ring

barbara michelle jacobs

2. Don’t guess on a size.

If you don’t know her ring size and want to find out (without ruining the surprise), use one of these to measure a ring she already loves to wear. Don’t assume the size; it won’t fit.

3. Do your research before you buy.

Avoid shady jewelry stores or pawn shops. Read about jewelry stores online and find out other shoppers’ comments before making a purchase. Find out about financing options, the return policy, and make sure you always get a certificate of authenticity when buying a diamond. Make sure the retailer is GIA-certified. And, make sure the ring comes with a warranty.

white gold engagement ring via 7 Tips for Picking an Engagement Ring

barbara michelle jacobs

4. Ask for her hand in marriage.

Ask her father for permission to marry his daughter. It means the world to her (and her family).

5. Don’t assume a custom ring always means more expensive (or difficult to do).

If she wants a custom ring (or you think a custom design suits her style best), don’t automatically assume it will cost too much. There are some fantastic custom rings in The Marketplace with artisans ready (and excited) to bring your design to fruition. For instance, if you have a family heirloom or vintage diamond you’d like to incorporate, a custom order is a great option. Barbara Michelle Jacobs Jewelry says they love to incorporate vintage diamonds in lieu of a brand new diamond (it’s more eco-friendly) for a custom order. (Find out more about vintage diamonds here.) Here’s an example of a vintage diamond set in a beautiful brand new setting:

vintage diamond in new ring setting via 7 Tips for Picking an Engagement Ring

barbara michelle jacobs

customized wine glasses

6. Buy what she wants.

It’s her ring and you want her to love it. She is, after all, going to be wearing it every day. Make sure you listen to what she wants and find a ring that suits her unique style and individuality.

7. Don’t become too obsessed with the size or cost.

What can you afford? Chances are you’ll have a certain budget in mind… stick to it. Don’t be pressured to get a certain size diamond or spend a certain amount of money. Love isn’t measured by the size of a diamond or the cost of it. Remember, the point of an engagement ring is the promise you make… and that is the most important part of all.


Now it’s your turn…

What engagement ring tips would you add to our list?

Tell us with a comment below!

Looking for engagement rings? Shop The Marketplace now!




emily bennette March 22, 2016 - 8:42 pm

I am trying to help my little brother pick out an engagement ring for his girlfriend. I like that you talked about how a custom ring might not mean the ring will be more expensive. That is a good thing for us to know because his girlfriend likes one several different style of rings. http://ringsutah.com/design/

Andria | Tahoe Unveiled May 13, 2014 - 2:31 pm

Really loving the natural look of these rings.

Emma | Emmaline Bride May 8, 2014 - 2:21 pm

Hi Rebecca! Thanks for your input. I understand not everyone agrees with the concept and we appreciate your opposing view. I don’t think anyone is owned by anyone; I like the idea of asking for one’s hand in marriage as a sign of respect. It’s a tradition, but I understand not all tradition or custom applies to everyone! Thanks for stopping by.

Amy - Chic Vintage Brides May 6, 2014 - 11:25 pm

Consider a vintage ring – I know, I know, I would say that! :) But actually there are a couple of great reasons for this, and not just because it is on trend right now. They are timeless (if they’re beautiful and loved 60-100 years after they were first made, then they will be in another 60-100 years! Vintage or modern timeless is key) they’re also eco-friendly, and there’s a romantic story behind every one!

Emma | Emmaline Bride May 8, 2014 - 2:22 pm

Yes, I love the idea of vintage rings, Amy, especially when the stone is an heirloom. Thanks for your comment!

Mark May 6, 2014 - 4:14 pm

Good ideas. One question though, if the father of the woman has passed away, who would you ask for her hand in marriage?

Emma | Emmaline Bride May 6, 2014 - 4:43 pm

Great question, Mark! In this case, you should ask her mother; another option is her older brother. The tradition of asking for her hand in marriage is a way to show your respect for the family and asking someone close to her is ideal.

Mark May 6, 2014 - 5:10 pm

Thanks for the quick response Emma.

Emma | Emmaline Bride May 8, 2014 - 2:22 pm

You got it!


Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

You'll also love...

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. By continuing to use this site, you confirm to the use of cookies. Accept Read More