Did you ever pop into a jewelry shop and come up with nothing? Yeah, me too. It’s a real bummer because you know good jewelry is out there, you’re just not sure where to shop… until now! Etsy is a masterful collection of makers and crafters, handmade jewelry shops and designers who follow their passion. If their devotion is jewelry, you bet your you-know-what you’re going to find awesome quality pieces: they make it their job to be the best Etsy shops for jewelry.

But, what are these jewelry stores, and which ones are the top makers? I’ll tell you! After years of working with many of these crafters admiring them from afar, or shopping their amazing collections, I’m here to give you my top picks for the best Etsy jewelry shops 2024 has to offer.

And when you’re gift-giving this season, consider shopping small: a real person does a real happy dance when you do, and that contributes to their passion! By shopping a small business, you can give a special gift that is handmade, custom, and one-of-a-kind. I think that’s pretty rad.

Let’s get started!

Top 10 Etsy Jewelry Shops

Browse our list of the top 10 shops below and scroll down to find out more about them.

1. Andrea Bonelli Jewelry

Andrea is a designer who creates some of the most amazing pieces I’ve seen from minimalist earrings to sparkling moissanite engagement rings. Her shop is known for its ethical jewelry and I absolutely love her collections.

She offers ready-to-ship jewelry pieces for gifts, or you can request a custom-made item. She offers bracelets, bands, necklaces, rings, and more. Shop here.

2. LeFaire

This jewelry shop has something for every minimalist in your life. The gold chain is simple, yet elegant: it is one of the top sellers. I love the horseshoe necklace, the acorn, the fern, and the dog bone for animal lovers. This shop is adorable: check it out here!

3. GLDNxLayeredAndLong

One-of-a-kind pieces with personalization is what you’ll find at this charming Etsy jewelry shop. You can shop for anyone in your life here and you’ll love the jewelry pieces. The ratings and reviews speak for themselves! Shop here.

4. Laura Stark

This rich red garnet bracelet has forever been a favorite of mine from Laura Stark’s collection. The jewelry in her shop can be best described as colorful and fun with gold accents that tie it all together so nicely. You’ll find incredible pieces here: shop now.

5. TomDesign

I could pick literal dozens of jewelry pieces from this Etsy shop, but the gemstone stud earrings are my favorite. Everyone I know wants a pair this holiday season and you can’t blame them: check out how gorgeous they are! They’re only $24 right now for a limited time. Shop here.

6. AmyWaltz

What can I say about Amy Waltz besides THIS SHOP IS SO INSPIRING! From the personalized cuff bracelets to the gorgeous raw stone rings to the stacking rings, you need to get acquainted with this shop ASAP. Get one of these cuffs and let it be your mantra for 2023 + doing all the best things in your life. Shop here.

7. GracePersonalized

Although there are plenty of amazing finds in this shop, the custom letter necklace is hands-down my favorite. I love the size of the letters: some Etsy shops offer jewelry that is too big, but these letters are juuuuuuuuust right. Shop here.

8. CraftArtJewelsGifts

For a bespoke gift, this is one of the best Etsy jewelry shops I’ve found yet. A birth flower necklace like the signature style makes such an amazing gift: it features her name and a birth flower in a unique vertical shape. This is a best-seller for sure. Browse this and other jewelry pieces here.

9. Frieda+Sophie

From crystal amethyst to moonstone, peach aragonite (below) to herkimer diamond (below that), you’ll find amazingly unique raw and rough stone jewelry at this shop. I love all of the pieces in the collection. Shop here.

10. Geominimalist

And last but not least, this Etsy shop for jewelry gets TONS of absolutely glowing reviews. This piece is one of the top-sellers and it’s one of my faves! Shop here.

What do you think of these picks? Do you have one to add to the list? I know there are dozens, but I wanted to highlight the 10 best Etsy jewelry shops in this list. If you’re looking for more designer and handcrafted jewelry, visit this link to discover more artisans.

Happy Shopping!

xo
Emma